RANT: A DISASTER with the Famed Christian Louboutin Pigalle 120!!!

I almost never swear, but this time, I really have to make a shout out to the world *W*T*F* happened to the Pigalle 120??!?! I’ve been meaning to write this post for the last 2 months, but I was so busy, so I must apologize. I hope that my pictures of the “old” and “new” Pigalle comparison will make up for the lost time here.

These shoes need little introduction, they are *THE* shoes that made the designer Christian Louboutin famous in the early millennium. He had designed rather average looking shoes that did not distinguish him from the mass, and in fact looked quite matronly and often followed the footsteps of the lead designer Manolo Blahnik at the time. However in 2004, he envisioned the Pigalle 120 – one that would elevate the foot and heighten one’s passionate desires. It was a unique design that was simple, elegant, and full of sex appeal. It has then since been the epitome of the brand and is his best selling shoes.

NewPigalle6

Now came Winter 2014, Monsieur Louboutin and his design team decided to CHANGE the famed shoe!!!
– How? By making the cut on the sides higher, dramatically changing the pitch to a very steep slope, turning the toe upward, and completely changing the sizing system. I’ve photoshopped the old Pigalle style with the new style for you guys to visually see the difference above.
– Why? Likely to appeal to the mass who find the Pigalle 120 style to be too uncomfortably narrow and therefore their feet “overhang” on the sides. By creating higher cut sides, it allows the shoe to envelope the feet without making it pop out for those who have difficulty wearing it.
I don’t have a problem with the brand making a shoe that will be better fitting for the mass. However, why not design a new shoe with a new name associated with it? He did not need to discontinue or change the old Pigalle at all. With his current fame, he can easily create a new style and women will still buy them off the shelves like crazy. I am also particularly disturbed by the fact that he is no longer following his own principles.

This is a man who once said to Vogue 2012, “it is not my job to create something comfortable. I try to make high heels as comfortable as they can be, but my priority is design, beauty and sexiness. I’m not against them, but comfort is not my focus.” Now making such a drastic change must have been a big decision in the company. I do give him the benefit of doubt that it was likely not him who gave the final word, given that his previous description and utter adoration of the Pigalle 120 style was just so full of passion. I don’t believe that he would sacrifice his design/style for comfort, but I do think that he’s a business man at heart and he is looking to appeal to the mass for more sales and profit.

When there’s compromise like this, I do believe that he will gain new customers, but will ultimately lose some of his most devoted fans – the original customers who first helped him to fame and recognized his design and style over anything else.

Please see the following pictures and let me know if you think the old (black) or new (nude) Pigalle is designed better. For reference, both are size 35, but the new Pigalle is very small and one needs to go up by at least half a size – I can barely squeeze my feet in them, whereas my old ones were a perfect fit.

NewPigalle1

NewPigalle3

 

Lined up against the wall, you can see clearly that the new nude Pigalle is a lot smaller. Heel to tip measurements: 18.8cm – 18.2cm = 0.6cm difference in length.

Pigalles1

Pigalles5

 

View of the sides: The nude pair is significantly higher cut and steeper in pitch. I think the heel height is a little different too by 0.2cm but this may just be a variation in hand-craftsmanship. The heel itself has not changed imo.

Pigalles2

Pigalles3

 

Measurement of sides (excluding outsole): 3.5cm – 2.75cm = 0.75cm difference!

Pigalles6

Vamp cut has changed too! The new style is actually lower cut and shows more toe cleavage by 0.3cm!

Pigalles7

More pix: Width has stayed the same otherwise.

Pigalles4

Pigalles8

 

More modeling pix of this disastrous shoe *sigh*
I understand that most people probably won’t even notice the difference, but for some of us CL fanatics, it’s heartbreaking and I just don’t feel the same wearing them. Even in the right size, I don’t think I can stand the steep pitch which makes me feel like I’m toppling over. My old black Pigalle fit perfectly!
N.B.: I know there has been rumors of the 100 style being changed too, but I tried them on and I really do not see a difference. It may be just that certain shoes have some variation in cut – most designers allow for upto 3mm of difference.

NewPigalle2

NewPigalle4

An ode to the old style:

Pigalle5

15 thoughts on “RANT: A DISASTER with the Famed Christian Louboutin Pigalle 120!!!

  1. The new pigalle is one deception,still beautiful,but isn´t Pigalle anymore.
    i was very lucky to win a pair of pigalle kid 120mm with the elastic,what miraculously appeared on CL´s site.
    we shall see when the precious box arrive.

  2. Disaster,disaster,disaster.
    Hello,Cecilia,i am a fan of Pigalle 120 since i saw this astonishing pairs for the first time.
    I could never buy one before,because they was incredible always sold out in my size,when ”the destiny seems what was conspirating” and i found them on the site of CL italia.Very well.I bought one pair(what was with the pic of the old Pigalle style)and what wasn´t my surprise to receive the new style in KID material?I am so pissed off,Cecilia,because i had problems also with the company what deliver the shoes,what couldn´t find my home to deliver this ”blessed” pairs.I am so pissed off with Louboutin what i will NEVER buy one single pair again,because they wasn´t sincere at all selling a chicken for one swan,if you understand what i mean.I simple called them and i said what i would be returning the shoes and i wanted a complete refund,because i will no accept what they sent me,one time what i felt me deeply damaged in my customer´s rights.

  3. Yes, please let CL customer service know of your dissatisfaction (like many of us) if the shoes don’t turn out to be as depicted. Best of luck!

  4. That black pair look absolutely divine on you! But those new Pigalles have got to go. They just look wrong on your lovely self. The new style just looks… way less elegant and more mass-produced.
    Why Louboutin, why.

  5. Thank you Miki!
    Yes, I still don’t understand why Mr Louboutin made this disastrous change. The fact that the new style is still flying off the shelves makes it harder to boycott and bring the old style back. We can only hope 🙂

  6. I am so happy I came across this informative blog. I recently went into the Louboutin store to try on the new pigalles and they look and feel so wrong!! The excessive toe clevage makes it look like you are trying to fit into a shoe that’s not your size! Would you recommend the so kates over the new pigalle 120?

  7. Hi Mel,

    You’re welcome! I’m sorry for replying back so late as I’ve been quite busy, but to answer your question, YES – I’d definitely recommend the So Kate (SK) over the new Pigalle 120. However lately I’ve tried the Pigalle Follie (PF) 120 which actually has a slightly lower cut side than the new Pigalle 120, and it’s a hybrid with the SK heel! You may want to give this a try too. The PF also comes in 100 mm which is quite comfortable, whereas the SK is only available in 120 at the moment. I’m not sure if heel height is a factor in your shopping, but hope this helps! 🙂

  8. I noticed you have your shoes fixe with rubber soles. do you have a cobbler who does this that you could recommend?

  9. Honestly, the new pigalle style looks cheap to me. It doesn’t have that elegant distinctive look that the old pigalle had. You could literally spot a pigalle without looking at the sole and now they look like some charlotte russe heel with a painted red sole.

  10. Thank for your post. It helped me a lot. I was thinking that something is wrong with my feet… I had exactly the same problem! I’m very disappointed about this differences. Besides, the customer service have to inform about it their clients!

  11. Thank for your post. It helped me a lot. I was thinking that something is wrong with my feet… I had exactly the same problem! I’m very disappointed about this differences. Besides, the customer service have to inform about it their clients!

  12. Oh thank goodness someone else noticed it. I can’t walk in the new version- and I mean, I look like bambi trying not to topple forward in them. I’m not sure why they’re designed for as I wear heels all the time but i cannot move in the new ones 🙁 heartbroken!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.